wordpress statistics

Zeno v. Claro Acne Treatment Devices, a Comparison

Comparing the Zeno and Claro Acne Treatment Devices: Treating Acne can be incredibly frustrating, especially if you are like me and have adult acne. I am in my 40s and still breaking out.  Fortunately, there are a couple of good treatment devices on the market that work rather well on standard pimples, and also have some effect on cystic acne, even through they are not marketed for use on that type of problem. I have written about both items separately in the past, but though a comparison chart would be helpful for readers who are considering purchasing an acne treatment device, but can’t decide on which one to try.

The Zeno Acne Treatment Device (link is to previous review) uses heat to kill bacteria and dry up acne, while the Claro Acne Clearing Device (link is to previous review) uses intense pulsed light (IPL) to kill bacteria.

Zeno Claro
Treatment Mechanism Heat Intense Pulsed Light (IPL)
Acne Types Treated Pimples, Pustules

Does not treat: Cystic Acne Whiteheads
Blackheads

Pimples, Pustules, Areas of Inflamed Acne

Does not treat:
Cystic Acne
Blackheads

Treatment Time 2.5 minutes Two six second treatments with a brief pause between treatments.
Comfort Comfortable heat. Must hold the device in place for 2.5 minutes. Comfortable heat.
Ease of Use Very easy. Device is easy to place and hold. Generally easy. Sometimes lining up the device or keeping it in contact with the skin is difficult.
Effectiveness Moderately effective.  The device works best on new acne and on mild acne. Clearing is hastened, but not complete within 24 hours. Not as effective on highly inflamed or severe acne. Had no meaningful effect on cystic acne (device is not marketed or recommended for use on cystic acne). Very effective on new and mild acne, giving clearing within 24 hours. Greatly assisted clearing on difficult and heavily inflamed acne. Cystic acne was lessened but not cleared (device is  not marketed or recommend for use on cystic acne).
Rechargeable Yes Yes
Product Life Varies among models.  The Zeno I reviewed lasts for 90 uses before a replacement tip must be purchased. 800 six second treatments.
Pros Easy to hold and use, very portable, comfortable. New Hot Spot Model is quite affordable. Quite effective and comfortable.
Cons Less effective on severe acne, takes 2.5 minutes for each treatment. Sometimes difficult to line up and keep in place, must wait one minute between each cycle of 2 treatments.
Price $150 (90 treatment model). Replacement tips run between $25-$35.

A New Zeno Hot Spot model offers 80 uses for $40.

$250 (800 treatments)

Between the two devices, I personally prefer the Claro, but I stick the Zeno in my bag when traveling because it is smaller and more portable. Zeno also has a new Hot Spot Acne Treatment Device that retails for around $40 and is good for 80 treatments. I have not tested that model, but it seems like a more affordable way to try out a Zeno device.

Note: The Claro portion of this review is based on a product that was given to me by a representative of the company. I purchased the Zeno on my own.   For more, please see my disclosure page.

Disclosures: Beauty and Fashion Tech at times reviews products provided by a representative of the company. When we do so, we specifically state so. We also use affiliate links. For more, please see the disclosure page

Claro Acne Clearing Device Review

Acne sufferers! Take notice of the CLARO Acne Clearing Device!  This intense pulsed light device (IPL) works quite well at clearing standard acne and, although not developed for use on cystic acne, had some effect on some that was bordering on being that type for me as well.  Before I give my Claro review, here is what the company says about it:Claro Acne Treatment Device

CLARO offers a completely new way to treat acne--no lotions, creams or pills. CLARO is a personal acne-treatment medical device that is based on the same Intense Pulsed Light (IPL) technology used by dermatologists worldwide. The IPL system used in the CLARO harnesses a powerful combination of heat and light to treat mild to moderate acne quickly and naturally. CLARO delivers a series of pulses in six seconds that safely penetrate the skin to target the cause of acne.The effective and natural treatment for acne:- Fast and easy to use.- Kills up to 94.8% of acne bacteria after just one treatment.- Results you'll notice quicker than with competitive devices.- Painless, gentle treatments.- Safe, with no side effects.- Natural alternative to drugs and lotions.- Portable, battery-operated and rechargeable. Color(s): cobalt blue, hot pink, onyx black.

I have been using the Claro for over a month now, with some particularly heavy use on a post-holiday breakout. I think all that bad eating didn’t do well for my skin!  I ran into a couple of minor difficulties using it, but overall I was quite happy with the results.

About the Claro Acne Treatment Device: The Claro uses a pulsed light laser to kill bacteria.  It also generates heat, something that also help treat acne.  It is formulated for use on standard pimples, not for use on cystic acne or blackheads.

Using the Claro Acne Clearing Device: To use the Claro, it is turned on and held over the pimple that is being treated. Two sensors on either side of the light must be in contact with the skin for the device to work. The unit beeps to let you know that contact is made. Then, the button is pressed and the device emits 12 pulses of light over 6 seconds.  After one treatment, the user is instructed to wait a few minutes and then treat the same area again. One pimple should be treated this way no more than once every 8 hours. After one set of two cycles, the device pauses and cant be used again for a minute. This is a safety feature to allow the device to cool.

I found that using the Claro Acne Treatment Device was generally easy and comfortable. It heats up slightly while emitting the IPL pulses, but it is not uncomfortable. If you have ever used a Zeno (link is to previous review), the sensation is similar.  It is not at all like the quick bursts of heat that come from the now discontinued Thermaclear (link is to previous review).  Where I ran into problems at times was lining up the device. It is a bit hard to tell if it is centered over the area of acne being treated, and I have contemplated drawing a black arrow on mine with a sharpie! Also, in areas where the face curves, such as the chin, it can be hard to keep both sensors in contact with the skin. This can result in the treatment cycle being cut short. I sometimes had both cycles cut off, and then had to wait for the device to allow me to use it again.

Effectiveness of the Claro: Here is the great part. I found the device to be very effective, and much more so than the Zeno was for me. The first time that I used it on an area of standard acne, it was practically gone the next day, with only a bit of redness remaining. Needless to say, I was impressed! Then, I tried it on an area that had several pimples, including a bit of particularly inflamed acne. It cleared the entire area up quite well.  Finally, I gave the Claro Device a try on a particularly difficult area of adult acne, that was bordering on being cystic acne, but not quite there yet--keep in mind that the Claro was not developed for use on cystic acne. It did not completely clear that one up, but I felt that it hastened its clearing—something I also feels that the Zeno and Thermaclear do with particularly inflamed or cystic acne. I think that heat generation might be the main cause of help when it comes to the tougher to treat types of breakouts. Again, the Claro does not advertise that it works on cystic acne, and does not recommend its use on that type, so there should be no expectations from it on that type of acne. Any such use is off label and not recommended by the company (or me for that matter). It also won't do a thing for blackheads, and is not recommended for use on them.

Safety of the Claro: Because the Claro uses a pulsed light laser, the user should never look into the light and it should be used with caution around the eyes. The device is shipped with a set of mini goggles if you would like extra eye protection.  I used them when treating an area underneath my one of eyes.

Price and Product Life: The Claro is $195.  Not mentioned on the sales page is that it also has a product life.  It will last for about 800 six second treatments, which if you are comparing it to the Zeno, comes to about equal in pricing since the Zeno is cheaper but needs its tips replaced more frequently.

Want it? Purchase a Claro

This review is based on a product that was sent to me by a representative of the company. For more, please see my disclosure page.

Disclosures: Beauty and Fashion Tech at times reviews products provided by a representative of the company. When we do so, we specifically state so. We also use affiliate links. For more, please see the disclosure page

Can You Reuse the Zeno Tip? No!

Zeno Acne Tip ReplacementI have been asked on a couple of occasions whether the Zeno Tip Cartridge can be reused. At first I did not definitely know the answer because the tip on mine had not yet expired. Now that it has, I can safely say that the answer is no.

When the device gets down to only a few uses left on the tip, the tip itself seems to quit heating up as effectively. I found that I was basically cheated out of my last 2 uses. Then it just quits and will not heat up at all. I took it off and put it back on to see it it would reset, and it did not. Basically, it appears to have a little chip in it that kills it after the set number of uses has run out.

I should also mention that even if I had found a way to re-use it, I would not recommend doing to. It really is best to follow the manufacturer's directions on such things. Regardless, I couldn't find a way to to cheat it.

Interested in acne treatment devices? Read my review of the Zeno and review of the ThermaClear.


Comparison shop for Zeno products

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Disclosures: Beauty and Fashion Tech at times reviews products provided by a representative of the company. When we do so, we specifically state so. We also use affiliate links. For more, please see the disclosure page